Nursing homes in Carmel, IN

Compare 8 Medicare- and Medicaid-certified nursing homes in Carmel, part of the Hamilton area. Average overall CMS Five-Star rating is 3.3★ — above the national average (3.1★). Ratings are sourced from the latest CMS Care Compare provider extract.

Residents of Carmel, Indiana, have access to 8 nursing homes located throughout Hamilton County, serving the 46032 and 46033 ZIP codes. According to CMS Care Compare data, these facilities hold an average overall rating of 3.2 out of 5 stars. The Barrington of Carmel, operated by BHI Senior Living, currently stands out as the city’s top-performing facility, maintaining a prestigious 5-star rating based on federal quality metrics.

What to look for in Carmel

• 2 homes score below 3★ on compliance. Ask about recent regulatory audits and any current notices.
• 2 of 8 homes meet a 4★+ staffing benchmark — ask about RN coverage at night.
• 1 home holds the top 5★ overall rating — a useful shortlist starting point.
• 4 of 8 homes sit below the national average (3.1★). Use the comparison tool to weigh trade-offs.

Top 8 highest rated nursing homes in Carmel

1. 1
   BARRINGTON OF CARMEL, THE

   BHI SENIOR LIVING · Small
   5.0
2. 2
   BRIDGEWATER HEALTHCARE CENTER

   COMMUNICARE HEALTH · Large
   4.0
3. 3
   RETREAT AT THE STRATFORD, THE

   SENIOR LIVING COMMUNITIES · Small
   4.0
4. 4
   RESTORACY OF CARMEL

   MAJOR HOSPITAL · Medium
   4.0
5. 5
   MAJESTIC CARE OF CARMEL

   MAJESTIC CARE · Medium
   3.0
6. 6
   WELLBROOKE OF CARMEL

   TRILOGY HEALTH SERVICES · Medium
   3.0
7. 7
   MCGIVNEY HEALTH CARE CENTER

   WITHAM MEMORIAL HOSPITAL · Small
   2.0
8. 8
   CARMEL HEALTH & LIVING COMMUNITY

   CARDON & ASSOCIATES · Large
   1.0

All homes in Carmel

Best by sub-rating in Carmel

Nearby suburbs in Hamilton